Wicked Cool PHP

By

This book review was published by Slashdot, 2008-04-07.

Wicked Cool PHP

Web developers familiar with a particular programming language, such as PHP, typically turn to books and forums for assistance only when they confront a specific problem that they believe has probably been encountered by many of their peers in the past, and who have published their answers in print or online. Hence the growing popularity of programming "cookbooks", which eschew flowing narratives in favor of self-contained problem descriptions and solutions. One example of a book that combines both styles is Wicked Cool PHP: Real-World Scripts That Solve Difficult Problems, by William Steinmetz with Brian Ward.

Published by No Starch Press on 9 February 2008, under the ISBN 978-1593271732, Wicked Cool PHP aims to provide the reader with a wide-ranging collection of complete PHP scripts and code fragments that solve specific problems frequently encountered by PHP coders. It is not intended for explaining the fundamentals of PHP, but assumes that the reader already understands the basics of the language. The book covers PHP versions 5 and 6. On the book's Web page, visitors can purchase it online, download a sample chapter (Chapter 4: Working with Forms), and download most of the sample code.

The book's material is organized into a dozen chapters, covering a range of topic areas: some simple scripts; configuring PHP; PHP security; forms; text and HTML; dates; files; user and session tracking; e-mail; images; using cURL to interact with Web services; and three intermediate projects. A brief appendix shows the MySQL commands for creating the product_info table used in many of the book's scripts. The book's back cover claims that it offers 76 scripts, but at least one section (#69) does not contain a script.

The first chapter is titled "The FAQs of Life — The Scripts Every PHP Programmer Wants (or Needs) to Know". That's quite a claim, unfulfilled by the chapter's material, which covers only seven narrow topics, such as how to include another file in a script (require_once) and how to print an array (print_r). Furthermore, there is no common theme for the scripts chosen, aside from their addressing questions that one of the authors — who is not identified — sees repeatedly in PHP forums and discussion groups. Some are extremely basic (e.g., print_r), while others address topics that are far more advanced and deserving lengthier treatment (e.g. templating your site with Smarty). That last topic would have been much better presented as an intermediate project in the book's final chapter.

Configuring PHP is an area that can prove perilous for programmers who are new to the language, and are, for whatever reason, having difficulty setting up PHP on their home Web server. For such individuals, Chapter 2 should prove quite useful, because it offers a clear overview of how they can configure their own PHP installations to match their needs. Some of the configuration advice could be a lifesaver, depending upon the reader's circumstances — such as the information on using open_basedir to limit directory access to PHP (and energetic hackers).

However, on page 20, when the authors provide advice on how the reader can find the php.ini file, they suggest that Windows users should look in "C:\php". Actually, the default installation file path is "C:\Program Files\PHP" (unless the reader has altered the value of ProgramFilesDir in the HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Windows\CurrentVersion key in their Windows Registry). They urge the reader to delete any phpinfo() script, for security reasons. But having such a script on a remote server could be quite valuable to the reader, at some point in the future; so it would be wiser to simply rename it, assuming that the reader has not allowed hackers to list file names on his or her Web server.

Several times in the book the authors advise the reader to set the error_reporting configuration option off for production servers — as well as for development servers lacking firewalls — so hackers and others do not see system information contained in error messages. But error_reporting is best used for specifying the level of error reporting, while the display_errors configuration option is best used for disabling the display of those errors to the site visitor. Errors should still be recorded in the Apache error log, so the developer can better diagnose what happened on a production site.

As with most first editions, this one contains several errata: "phpinfo()can" (page 21), "data to encrypted" (page 42), "six years" (page 55; should be 10 years, to match the code), and "timestamp() function" (page 82; should be "time() function").

In any book, a sizable number of minor flaws will prompt the careful reader to begin questioning the editing of the book. This is especially true when encountered in the first paragraph of the first page of the Introduction: "stumbled on to", which should instead be two words. But it goes beyond just issues of line editing — to a question of judgment. That very first page also contains "After you calm down", which is too flippant for what should be a professional work, as are other instances: "living hell" (page 4), "hash-ish" (page 40), and "Mac users... [like] to buy expensive gadgets for the sole purpose of looking stylish" (page 113). The authors frequently use the term "I" without specifying which author is being referred to; presumably it is the first author listed. On page 64, they state that they had previously mentioned the === operator, but I cannot find it anywhere, and neither could whoever created the book's index.

In the sample code, the authors use double quotation marks — instead of single ones — for most of the strings, few of which contain variables. This slows down the PHP interpreter by forcing it to check for variables within the strings, to be interpolated. Moreover, they are not consistent in the usage — occasionally switching over to single quotes instead, for no apparent reason. The same is true of in-line comments, which switch back and forth between Java and C styles.

The code in general is not entirely consistent throughout the book, e.g., using print() in most cases, but echo() in the remaining ones, with no explanation as to why. Perhaps this is the result of having two authors. Most HTML tag names are in lowercase, but a couple are in uppercase.

Some of the book's code appears invalid. For instance, on page 5, one of the statements (abbreviated here), echo "$row[product_name]", generates two errors: "unexpected T_ENCAPSED_AND_WHITESPACE" and "Use of undefined constant key - assumed 'product_name'". The correct code would be: echo "{$row[ 'product_name' ]}". On page 41, $cipher is set to the string "MCRYPT_SERPENT_256", which generates an error, and probably instead should be set to the constant MCRYPT_SERPENT, which works fine. $mode is set to the string "MCRYPT_MODE_CBC", but that should be a constant as well. On page 72, the regex pattern for matching HTML anchor tags does not match an entire opening tag, but just a portion of it. In the downloadable code for section #68, getpage.php fails because "<?" should be "<?php". Readers shouldn't have to debug a book's code just to get it to run without error. Did no one test the sample code before publication?! In the code for section #71, mapdemo.php generates index errors when run without any GET parameters, and does not generate a map when values are entered in the form.

Some of the code may work in certain circumstances, but not in others. For example, on page 70, the pipe character (|) is recommended as a substitute for the forward slash (/) for regex patterns containing many such slashes. But the pipe character is a very poor choice, because it has a special meaning in regex patterns, namely, as the 'or' operator, and thus cannot be used for any pattern that needs to use that operator. In section #49, calculate_time_difference() fails if one or both of the timestamps is the epoch time (time zero). In section #61, get_ip() assumes that two $_SERVER keys are set, and fails when they are not.

Some of the code works but can give beginners the wrong impression. For instance, on page 25, the authors present a configuration setting (incorrectly referred to as an "extension"): ini_set(max_execution_time, "240"). But max_execution_time is not placed in quotation marks. Even though this does not cause an error, a newbie may do the same with ini_get(), and become confused as to why PHP then (rightly) complains. (One could argue that PHP should also flag the ini_set() call as erroneous.) Section #50 could mislead newbie programmers into using that multi-line script instead of PHP's file_get_contents(). Section #51 similarly re-creates the wheel, namely, file_put_contents().

Lastly, some of the code, comments, and variable naming choices are quite puzzling. For instance, in section #30, validate_cc_number defines a variable as $false = false, but this "variable" never gets changed in the rest of the script. That is what constants are for. In the downloadable time difference scripts for Chapter 6, we find "print abs(5 - 62);" with no apparent purpose. In timediff.php, calculate_time_difference() checks for divide by zero errors for a variable that is never used as a denominator.

Unlike most computer programming books, this one has no acknowledgments of any technical reviewers. Given all of the problems in the code, it is possible that there actually were no technical reviewers, though it is difficult to imagine any reason why a publisher would choose that unwise route.

In terms of formatting of the material in the book, most of the left-hand pages (the even-numbered ones) have the page contents shifted too far to the right, almost running into the crease of the book, and leaving a glaring amount of wasted whitespace in the left-hand margin. The only exceptions are on pages 163, 164, and 172, where portions of code awkwardly jut out into the left margin.

The downloadable code archive is quite flawed, and a fair amount of the code needs to be cleaned up. For example, getpage.php contains a lot of redundant code. Much of the sample code in the book is not included in the archive; incredibly, this includes some of the largest scripts, such as the Smarty code in Chapter 1 and the credit card processing code in Chapter 4. In fact, the archive is missing the code for two entire chapters (2 and 3). Oddly enough, at least a couple scripts in the archive are not mentioned in the book. The archive needs a complete overhaul, including the cleanup or elimination of seemingly leftover scripts such as foo.php (three instances) and captcha_old.php.

On the positive side of the ledger, the book contains information that would be of interest to all levels of PHP programmers. For instance, readers who are just barely familiar with the language will benefit from the discussions concerning superglobals, form input security, date and file manipulation, and how to save user information with sessions and cookies. More advanced developers may profit from the discussions on encryption, PHPMailer, captchas, Web services, and other topics generally found later in the book.

In addition, many of the sections include a special subsection titled "What Can Go Wrong?", in which the authors consider potential problems with the code or overall approach presented in that section. Undoubtedly other technical books provide such information, interwoven with the main narrative; but explicitly identifying potential pitfalls is a worthy practice — one that we can only hope to see in other programming books in the future.

At 224 pages, it is a relatively slim volume, but contains a fair amount of useful information relative to its size — a pithiness welcome in the world of computer books. (Fortunately, the trend in the technical publishing world has shifted away from tomes sometimes exceeding 1000 pages that are padded with poorly-edited material shoveled in by multiple authors.)

Yet all in all, Wicked Cool PHP is largely disappointing. It contains no PHP scripts that could be considered "wicked cool". Moreover, the aforementioned code problems clearly call for an improved second edition, including a complete revision of the downloadable code archive. On the other hand, Wicked Cool PHP touches upon a number of key topics in PHP programming, with minimal fluff, and gets right to the point.

Copyright © 2008 Michael J. Ross. All rights reserved.

This book is available on Amazon

Content topics: 
Publisher: